{ "chain": { "slug": "space-debris", "name": "Orbital debris and its downstream products", "cutoff": "2025-12-31", "hypothesis": "stated by the author; the dependencies block below is the measurement of them", "why": "Chosen because it is dull enough to measure honestly: a root everyone agrees exists, four products the record can be checked for, and no company to root for.", "edges": [ { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "active-debris-removal" }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "debris-shielding" }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "on-orbit-servicing" }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "small-satellites" }, { "cited": "small-satellites", "citing": "orbital-debris" } ] }, "capabilities": [ { "slug": "orbital-debris", "name": "Orbital debris", "queries": { "research": { "terms": [ "orbital debris", "space debris" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "funding": { "terms": [ "orbital debris", "space debris" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "testing": { "terms": [], "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware", "measured": false }, "regulation": { "terms": [ "orbital debris", "space debris" ], "reason": null, "measured": true } }, "trajectory": { "research": { "works": { "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 113, 186, 159, 121, 174, 182, 220, 200, 184, 307, 298, 290, 368, 459, 484, 504, 545, 682, 525, 734, 602, 638, 621, 727, 955, 1223 ] } }, "funding": { "awards": { "source": "nsf", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 2, 0, 0, 0, 4, 0, 0, 0, 2, 4, 1, 3, 3, 4, 6, 7 ] } }, "testing": { "measured": false, "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware" }, "regulation": { "final rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 2, 0, 1, 2, 5, 2, 4, 0, 2, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 2, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 5, 2, 0, 3, 5, 2 ] }, "proposed rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 1, 2, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 3, 5, 3, 2, 3, 5, 7, 3 ] } } }, "confidence": { "measured": false, "reason": "the root is what the products are scored against" } }, { "slug": "active-debris-removal", "name": "Active debris removal", "queries": { "research": { "terms": [ "active debris removal" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "funding": { "terms": [ "active debris removal", "space debris removal" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "testing": { "terms": [], "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware", "measured": false }, "regulation": { "terms": [ "active debris removal" ], "reason": null, "measured": true } }, "trajectory": { "research": { "works": { "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 3, 11, 12, 16, 26, 42, 42, 64, 67, 79, 61, 63, 68, 73, 74, 81, 113, 141 ] } }, "funding": { "awards": { "source": "nsf", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0 ] } }, "testing": { "measured": false, "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware" }, "regulation": { "final rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "proposed rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0 ] } } }, "confidence": { "score": 0.4803802239302978, "label": "moderate", "barriers_sampled": true, "components": { "growth": 0.5122260239263191, "dependency": 0.8092948717948718, "precedence": 1.0, "stages": 1.0, "barriers": -0.35 }, "basis": [ "growth: 0.51 on a log scale where the mature control sits at 0 (11.9x) and the boom control at 1 (16,491x); smoothed growth 483x against the index's 2.6x, and no works in 2000-2004, so the ratio is the +1 smoothing alone", "dependency: 0.81 of the product's works with recorded references cite at least one root work (reference coverage 0.60 of 1,037 works; 2,763 of 16,526 references land in the root's 10,941 works)", "precedence: the root crossed a tenth of its peak in 2001, before the product in 2011", "stages: 3 of 3 measured stages show signal (research 1,038, funding 4, regulation 6); testing unmeasured", "barriers: 6 physical, 1 economic on 7 distinct sentences of 7 recorded; component -0.35", "score: 0.48 = mean of 4 determined components (0.83) with the barrier penalty (-0.35); labelled moderate", "an evidence score over one chain, anchored to two controls; not a calibrated probability" ] } }, { "slug": "debris-shielding", "name": "Debris shielding", "queries": { "research": { "terms": [ "micrometeoroid" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "funding": { "terms": [ "micrometeoroid" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "testing": { "terms": [], "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware", "measured": false }, "regulation": { "terms": [ "micrometeoroid" ], "reason": null, "measured": true } }, "trajectory": { "research": { "works": { "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 22, 26, 38, 36, 36, 32, 38, 33, 43, 59, 64, 56, 52, 47, 85, 57, 68, 69, 53, 69, 63, 67, 65, 76, 105, 128 ] } }, "funding": { "awards": { "source": "nsf", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, "testing": { "measured": false, "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware" }, "regulation": { "final rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0 ] }, "proposed rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0 ] } } }, "confidence": { "score": 0.4290822407628128, "label": "moderate (barriers unsampled)", "barriers_sampled": false, "components": { "growth": 0.0, "dependency": 0.2872467222884386, "precedence": null, "stages": 1.0, "barriers": 0.0 }, "basis": [ "growth: 0.00 on a log scale where the mature control sits at 0 (11.9x) and the boom control at 1 (16,491x), clamped at the mature control; smoothed growth 2.8x against the index's 2.6x", "dependency: 0.29 of the product's works with recorded references cite at least one root work (reference coverage 0.56 of 1,487 works; 774 of 27,836 references land in the root's 10,928 works)", "precedence: undetermined at this window (the product crossed a tenth of its peak in 2000, the window's first year)", "stages: 3 of 3 measured stages show signal (research 1,487, funding 5, regulation 3); testing unmeasured", "barriers: not sampled for this product; component 0.00 and not comparable to a product whose barriers were sampled", "score: 0.43 = mean of 3 determined components (0.43), precedence undetermined, with the barrier penalty (0.00); labelled moderate (barriers unsampled)", "an evidence score over one chain, anchored to two controls; not a calibrated probability" ] } }, { "slug": "on-orbit-servicing", "name": "On-orbit servicing", "queries": { "research": { "terms": [ "on-orbit servicing", "in-orbit servicing" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "funding": { "terms": [ "on-orbit servicing", "in-orbit servicing" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "testing": { "terms": [], "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware", "measured": false }, "regulation": { "terms": [ "on-orbit servicing" ], "reason": null, "measured": true } }, "trajectory": { "research": { "works": { "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 15, 14, 27, 21, 27, 24, 40, 25, 29, 44, 44, 68, 69, 81, 84, 68, 92, 76, 95, 108, 138, 150, 159, 202, 239, 334 ] } }, "funding": { "awards": { "source": "nsf", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 2, 1, 0, 2, 0 ] } }, "testing": { "measured": false, "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware" }, "regulation": { "final rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 2, 1, 3, 1 ] }, "proposed rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 1, 2, 2 ] } } }, "confidence": { "score": 0.5901403956604978, "label": "moderate (barriers unsampled)", "barriers_sampled": false, "components": { "growth": 0.0, "dependency": 0.36056158264199106, "precedence": 1.0, "stages": 1.0, "barriers": 0.0 }, "basis": [ "growth: 0.00 on a log scale where the mature control sits at 0 (11.9x) and the boom control at 1 (16,491x), clamped at the mature control; smoothed growth 10.3x against the index's 2.6x", "dependency: 0.36 of the product's works with recorded references cite at least one root work (reference coverage 0.69 of 2,272 works; 1,711 of 40,281 references land in the root's 11,161 works)", "precedence: the root crossed a tenth of its peak in 2001, before the product in 2006", "stages: 3 of 3 measured stages show signal (research 2,273, funding 6, regulation 17); testing unmeasured", "barriers: not sampled for this product; component 0.00 and not comparable to a product whose barriers were sampled", "score: 0.59 = mean of 4 determined components (0.59) with the barrier penalty (0.00); labelled moderate (barriers unsampled)", "an evidence score over one chain, anchored to two controls; not a calibrated probability" ] } }, { "slug": "small-satellites", "name": "Small satellites", "queries": { "research": { "terms": [ "small satellite", "cubesat" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "funding": { "terms": [ "small satellite", "cubesat" ], "reason": null, "measured": true }, "testing": { "terms": [], "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware", "measured": false }, "regulation": { "terms": [ "small satellite" ], "reason": null, "measured": true } }, "trajectory": { "research": { "works": { "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 197, 202, 348, 320, 287, 287, 365, 304, 409, 545, 540, 567, 669, 843, 889, 1136, 1260, 1417, 1625, 1797, 1874, 1574, 1365, 1585, 1824, 2826 ] } }, "funding": { "awards": { "source": "nsf", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 3, 10, 11, 6, 6, 7, 10, 10, 8, 5, 9, 2, 29, 9, 5, 3, 6, 6, 3 ] } }, "testing": { "measured": false, "reason": "no trial registry covers spaceflight hardware" }, "regulation": { "final rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 1, 1, 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 4, 1, 3, 2, 3, 2, 3, 2 ] }, "proposed rules": { "source": "federal_register", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 0, 0, 1, 2, 2, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 3, 3, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4, 5 ] } } }, "confidence": { "score": 0.5149214063330549, "label": "moderate (barriers unsampled)", "barriers_sampled": false, "components": { "growth": 0.0, "dependency": 0.059685625332219605, "precedence": 1.0, "stages": 1.0, "barriers": 0.0 }, "basis": [ "growth: 0.00 on a log scale where the mature control sits at 0 (11.9x) and the boom control at 1 (16,491x), clamped at the mature control; smoothed growth 6.8x against the index's 2.6x", "dependency: 0.06 of the product's works with recorded references cite at least one root work (reference coverage 0.53 of 25,009 works; 1,740 of 266,333 references land in the root's 10,894 works)", "precedence: the root crossed a tenth of its peak in 2001, before the product in 2002", "stages: 3 of 3 measured stages show signal (research 25,055, funding 150, regulation 70); testing unmeasured", "barriers: not sampled for this product; component 0.00 and not comparable to a product whose barriers were sampled", "score: 0.51 = mean of 4 determined components (0.51) with the barrier penalty (0.00); labelled moderate (barriers unsampled)", "an evidence score over one chain, anchored to two controls; not a calibrated probability" ] } } ], "dependencies": [ { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "active-debris-removal", "citing_works": 1037, "citing_with_refs": 624, "refs_total": 16526, "refs_in_cited": 0, "works_citing_any": 0, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.0, "reach": 0.0 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "active-debris-removal", "citing_works": 1037, "citing_with_refs": 624, "refs_total": 16526, "refs_in_cited": 0, "works_citing_any": 0, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.0, "reach": 0.0 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "debris-shielding", "citing_works": 1487, "citing_with_refs": 839, "refs_total": 27836, "refs_in_cited": 0, "works_citing_any": 0, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.0, "reach": 0.0 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "debris-shielding", "citing_works": 1487, "citing_with_refs": 839, "refs_total": 27836, "refs_in_cited": 0, "works_citing_any": 0, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.0, "reach": 0.0 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "on-orbit-servicing", "citing_works": 2272, "citing_with_refs": 1567, "refs_total": 40281, "refs_in_cited": 0, "works_citing_any": 0, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.0, "reach": 0.0 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "on-orbit-servicing", "citing_works": 2272, "citing_with_refs": 1567, "refs_total": 40281, "refs_in_cited": 0, "works_citing_any": 0, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.0, "reach": 0.0 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "small-satellites", "citing_works": 25009, "citing_with_refs": 13169, "refs_total": 266333, "refs_in_cited": 1, "works_citing_any": 1, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 3.754698065955026e-06, "reach": 7.593591009188245e-05 }, { "cited": "barcode-scanner", "citing": "small-satellites", "citing_works": 25009, "citing_with_refs": 13169, "refs_total": 266333, "refs_in_cited": 1, "works_citing_any": 1, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 920, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 3.754698065955026e-06, "reach": 7.593591009188245e-05 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "active-debris-removal", "citing_works": 1037, "citing_with_refs": 624, "refs_total": 16526, "refs_in_cited": 2763, "works_citing_any": 505, "overlap_excluded": 535, "cited_works": 10941, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.16719109282342975, "reach": 0.8092948717948718 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "active-debris-removal", "citing_works": 502, "citing_with_refs": 285, "refs_total": 7733, "refs_in_cited": 1302, "works_citing_any": 240, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 11476, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 535, "share": 0.16836932626406312, "reach": 0.8421052631578947 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "debris-shielding", "citing_works": 1487, "citing_with_refs": 839, "refs_total": 27836, "refs_in_cited": 774, "works_citing_any": 241, "overlap_excluded": 548, "cited_works": 10928, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.027805719212530534, "reach": 0.2872467222884386 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "debris-shielding", "citing_works": 939, "citing_with_refs": 536, "refs_total": 21931, "refs_in_cited": 183, "works_citing_any": 76, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 11476, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 548, "share": 0.008344352742692992, "reach": 0.1417910447761194 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "on-orbit-servicing", "citing_works": 2272, "citing_with_refs": 1567, "refs_total": 40281, "refs_in_cited": 1711, "works_citing_any": 565, "overlap_excluded": 315, "cited_works": 11161, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.042476601871850254, "reach": 0.36056158264199106 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "on-orbit-servicing", "citing_works": 1957, "citing_with_refs": 1351, "refs_total": 33292, "refs_in_cited": 1724, "works_citing_any": 573, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 11476, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 315, "share": 0.05178421242340502, "reach": 0.4241302738712065 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "small-satellites", "citing_works": 25009, "citing_with_refs": 13169, "refs_total": 266333, "refs_in_cited": 1740, "works_citing_any": 786, "overlap_excluded": 582, "cited_works": 10894, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.006533174634761746, "reach": 0.059685625332219605 }, { "cited": "orbital-debris", "citing": "small-satellites", "citing_works": 24427, "citing_with_refs": 12850, "refs_total": 261389, "refs_in_cited": 1505, "works_citing_any": 864, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 11476, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 582, "share": 0.005757702122124496, "reach": 0.06723735408560311 }, { "cited": "small-satellites", "citing": "orbital-debris", "citing_works": 11476, "citing_with_refs": 6343, "refs_total": 131125, "refs_in_cited": 1464, "works_citing_any": 778, "overlap_excluded": 582, "cited_works": 24427, "overlap_kept": true, "overlap_dropped": 0, "share": 0.011164918970448046, "reach": 0.12265489516001891 }, { "cited": "small-satellites", "citing": "orbital-debris", "citing_works": 10894, "citing_with_refs": 6024, "refs_total": 126181, "refs_in_cited": 1837, "works_citing_any": 1009, "overlap_excluded": 0, "cited_works": 25009, "overlap_kept": false, "overlap_dropped": 582, "share": 0.014558451747885974, "reach": 0.16749667994687914 } ], "documents": [ { "doc_id": "2014-20578", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2014-09-03", "title": "Rules Governing the Licensing of, and Spectrum Usage by, Commercial Earth Stations and Space Stations", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 20", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2016-14800", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2016-08-18", "title": "Comprehensive Review of Licensing and Operating Rules for Satellite Services", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 19", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2017-04768", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2017-03-10", "title": "List of Office of Management and Budget Approved Information Collection Requirements", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 18", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2020-10703", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2020-05-20", "title": "Licensing of Private Remote Sensing Space Systems", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 17", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2020-11348", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2020-06-22", "title": "Assessment and Collection of Regulatory Fees for Fiscal Year 2020", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 16", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2020-12013", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2020-07-20", "title": "Streamlining Licensing Procedures for Small Satellites", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 15", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2020-13185", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2020-08-25", "title": "Mitigation of Orbital Debris in the New Space Age", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 14", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2020-22042", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2020-12-10", "title": "Streamlined Launch and Reentry License Requirements", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 13", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2021-13685", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2021-06-28", "title": "Allocation of Spectrum for Non-Federal Space Launch Operations", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 12", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2021-20193", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2021-09-20", "title": "Mitigation of Orbital Debris in the New Space Age", "selected_for": [ "barriers", "relevance" ], "selection": "orbital-debris-titled final rule, newest rank 3; most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 11", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2023-12803", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2023-06-20", "title": "Revising Spectrum Sharing Rules for Non-Geostationary Orbit, Fixed-Satellite Service Systems", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 10", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2023-13503", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2023-07-10", "title": "Expanding Flexible Use of the 12.2-12.7 GHz Band", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 9", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2023-26699", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2023-12-06", "title": "Expediting Initial Processing of Satellite and Earth Station Applications", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 8", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2024-03506", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2024-02-22", "title": "Mitigation of Orbital Debris in the New Space Age", "selected_for": [ "barriers", "relevance" ], "selection": "orbital-debris-titled final rule, newest rank 2; most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 7", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2024-16638", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2024-08-05", "title": "Allocation of Spectrum for Non-Federal Space Launch Operations; Federal Earth Stations Communicating With Non-Federal Fixed Satellite Service Space Stations; and Federal Space Station Use of the 399.9-400.05 MHz Band", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 6", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2024-17093", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2024-08-09", "title": "Space Innovation; Mitigation of Orbital Debris in the New Space Age", "selected_for": [ "barriers", "relevance" ], "selection": "orbital-debris-titled final rule, newest rank 1; most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 5", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2024-21159", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2024-09-25", "title": "Review of the Commission's Assessment and Collection of Regulatory Fees for Fiscal Year 2024; Assessment and Collection of Space and Earth Station Regulatory Fees for Fiscal Year 2024, Second Report and Order", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 4", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2024-28424", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2024-12-04", "title": "Single Network Future: Supplemental Coverage From Space Information Collection Approval for Space Station and Earth Station Applications", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 3", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2025-12579", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2025-07-07", "title": "Assessment and Collection of Space and Earth Station Regulatory Fees for Fiscal Year 2024", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 2", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2025-16375", "source": "federal_register", "published": "2025-08-27", "title": "Expediting Initial Processing of Satellite and Earth Station Applications; Space Innovation", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris final rule rank 1", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2128578", "source": "nsf", "published": "2021-08-10", "title": "Modeling, Design and Operation of Robotic Tether-Net Systems for Reliable Capture of Targets", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "NSF award for the ADR funding terms", "candidates": 2 }, { "doc_id": "2149585", "source": "nsf", "published": "2022-06-03", "title": "Dexterous Magnetic Manipulation of Non-Magnetic Objects with Stationary Electromagnetic Dipole-Field Sources", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 19", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2208458", "source": "nsf", "published": "2022-04-04", "title": "EAGER: DCL: SaTC: Enabling Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Space Cybersecurity, Policy, and Risks", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 20", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2227213", "source": "nsf", "published": "2023-09-08", "title": "STTR Phase I: Space Debris Awareness Spectrum", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 15", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2229756", "source": "nsf", "published": "2022-12-15", "title": "RII Track-4 NSF: Robust, Predictive, and Learning Guidance Algorithms for On-Orbit Servicing and Assembly Using Multiple Space Systems", "selected_for": [ "barriers", "relevance" ], "selection": "NSF award for the ADR funding terms; most-recent orbital-debris award rank 18", "candidates": 2 }, { "doc_id": "2233424", "source": "nsf", "published": "2023-04-03", "title": "STTR Phase I: Hyper Transfer Vehicle Concept Demonstration", "selected_for": [ "barriers", "relevance" ], "selection": "NSF award for the ADR funding terms; most-recent orbital-debris award rank 17", "candidates": 2 }, { "doc_id": "2323566", "source": "nsf", "published": "2024-01-25", "title": "SBIR Phase I: Silane Recycling from Decommissioned Photovoltaics using Microgravity-analog Fluidized Bed Reactor with Sonication.", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 13", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2327424", "source": "nsf", "published": "2023-11-24", "title": "RII Track-4: NSF: Self-healing Modular Panels for Space and Lunar Missions", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 14", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2328383", "source": "nsf", "published": "2023-08-22", "title": "FMRG: Eco: GOALI: CAS: Understanding the Sustainability Framework for Convergent In-Space Manufacturing", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 16", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2335156", "source": "nsf", "published": "2024-06-12", "title": "SBIR Phase I: Universal Electric Propulsion System Gridded Hall Thruster For Satellite Life Extension And Space Debris Removal", "selected_for": [ "barriers", "relevance" ], "selection": "NSF award for the ADR funding terms; most-recent orbital-debris award rank 10", "candidates": 3 }, { "doc_id": "2343844", "source": "nsf", "published": "2024-02-05", "title": "Thermospheric Estimation and CHaracterization with Nitric Oxide (TECHNO)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 12", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2404362", "source": "nsf", "published": "2024-06-21", "title": "SBIR Phase I: Space-Time Projection Optical Tomography (SPOT)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 9", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2423107", "source": "nsf", "published": "2024-09-05", "title": "SBIR Phase II: Advanced propulsion system for spacecraft based on the Unresolved Longitudinal Ampere Tension Forces in Conductors", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 8", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2423467", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-03-05", "title": "Collaborative Research: ISS: Segregation of Inhomogeneous Alloy Melt Driven by Capillary Flow in Microgravity", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 7", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2423468", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-03-05", "title": "Collaborative Research: ISS: Segregation of Inhomogeneous Alloy Melt Driven by Capillary Flow in Microgravity", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 6", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2423904", "source": "nsf", "published": "2024-04-30", "title": "I-Corps: Translation potential of self-neutralizing, air-breathing plasma propulsion", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 11", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2435391", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-05-29", "title": "IUCRC Planning Grant Penn State University: Center for Research in Emerging Sustainable Space Technologies (CRES2T)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 4", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2435409", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-06-17", "title": "IUCRC Planning Grant Texas A&M University: Center for Research in Emerging Sustainable Space Technologies (CRES2T)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 2", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2435453", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-05-29", "title": "IUCRC Planning Grant Purdue University: Center for Research in Emerging Sustainable Space Technologies (CRES2T)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 3", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2507479", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-03-24", "title": "Conference: The Impacts of a Growing Space Industry on Earth's Atmosphere--Research Challenges and Opportunities", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 5", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "2530577", "source": "nsf", "published": "2025-07-31", "title": "Robust and Dynamics-Aware Active Perception for Space Robotics", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris award rank 1", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W1831468128", "source": "openalex", "published": "2013-01-01", "title": "Uncooperative Rendezvous and Docking for MicroSats", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 8", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W1970733794", "source": "openalex", "published": "2014-06-26", "title": "Rollable Multisegment Dielectric Elastomer Minimum Energy Structures for a Deployable Microsatellite Gripper", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 1", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2012772810", "source": "openalex", "published": "2015-07-07", "title": "Evolving Solutions to TSP Variants for Active Space Debris Removal", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 9", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2065606305", "source": "openalex", "published": "2015-03-16", "title": "A Model-Based 3D Template Matching Technique for Pose Acquisition of an Uncooperative Space Object", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 4", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2089271685", "source": "openalex", "published": "2013-01-01", "title": "Engineering and technology challenges for active debris removal", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 3", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2119010293", "source": "openalex", "published": "2014-03-08", "title": "Towards a deployable satellite gripper based on multisegment dielectric elastomer minimum energy structures", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 4", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2135707370", "source": "openalex", "published": "2011-02-01", "title": "Effect of thermospheric contraction on remediation of the near-Earth space debris environment", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 2", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2153167938", "source": "openalex", "published": "2013-01-01", "title": "Results of PRISMA/FFIORD extended mission and applicability to future formation flying and active debris removal missions", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 5", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2165957868", "source": "openalex", "published": "2013-01-01", "title": "Active Debris Removal mission design in Low Earth Orbit", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 7", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2513170065", "source": "openalex", "published": "2016-09-09", "title": "Guidance, Navigation, and Control for the Eddy Brake Method", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 7", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2554721177", "source": "openalex", "published": "2016-11-23", "title": "Contact Dynamics Modeling and Simulation of Tether Nets for Space-Debris Capture", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 2", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2562805452", "source": "openalex", "published": "2012-01-01", "title": "Active space debris removal by hybrid engine module", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 10", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2568139125", "source": "openalex", "published": "2017-01-10", "title": "Pose Estimation for Spacecraft Relative Navigation Using Model-Based Algorithms", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 1", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2763294041", "source": "openalex", "published": "2017-10-04", "title": "Optimization of Active Debris Removal Missions with Multiple Targets", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 8", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2788921116", "source": "openalex", "published": "2018-02-19", "title": "Robotics and AI-Enabled On-Orbit Operations With Future Generation of Small Satellites", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 6", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2790442549", "source": "openalex", "published": "2018-02-23", "title": "High-Performance Embedded Computing in Space: Evaluation of Platforms for Vision-Based Navigation", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 3", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W2918830366", "source": "openalex", "published": "2019-03-04", "title": "Multitarget Rendezvous for Active Debris Removal Using Multiple Spacecraft", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 10", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2941256449", "source": "openalex", "published": "2019-04-26", "title": "Tutorial Review on Space Manipulators for Space Debris Mitigation", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2015-2019 rank 5", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W2997189294", "source": "openalex", "published": "2020-01-05", "title": "CNN-Based Pose Estimation System for Close-Proximity Operations Around Uncooperative Spacecraft", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 7", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W3028737585", "source": "openalex", "published": "2020-05-26", "title": "Orbital-use fees could more than quadruple the value of the space industry", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 1", "candidates": 4 }, { "doc_id": "W3041054007", "source": "openalex", "published": "2020-07-07", "title": "Space robot motion planning in the presence of nonconserved linear and angular momenta", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 6", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W3129617083", "source": "openalex", "published": "2021-02-15", "title": "Evaluation of tightly- and loosely-coupled approaches in CNN-based pose estimation systems for uncooperative spacecraft", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 3", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W3212496839", "source": "openalex", "published": "2021-11-10", "title": "Capture and detumbling control for active debris removal by a dual-arm space robot", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 4", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W4223627349", "source": "openalex", "published": "2022-04-09", "title": "On-ground validation of a CNN-based monocular pose estimation system for uncooperative spacecraft: Bridging domain shift in rendezvous scenarios", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 5", "candidates": 2 }, { "doc_id": "W4281488473", "source": "openalex", "published": "2022-05-25", "title": "Monocular Relative Pose Estimation Pipeline for Uncooperative Resident Space Objects", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 8", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W4321614190", "source": "openalex", "published": "2023-02-23", "title": "Design and guidance of a multi-active debris removal mission", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 2", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W4392923947", "source": "openalex", "published": "2024-03-01", "title": "An introductory review of swarm technology for spacecraft on\u2010orbit servicing", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 10", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W4409983556", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-01-01", "title": "Review of Autonomous Space Robotic Manipulators for On-Orbit Servicing and Active Debris Removal", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2020-2025 rank 9", "candidates": 1 }, { "doc_id": "W7117448019", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-27", "title": "EVOLUTION OF THE ROTATION PARAMETERS OF THE ROCKET\u2019S UPPER STAGE (SPACE OBJECT 1987-074G)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 15", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117453191", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-29", "title": "A study on the polarization aberration correction method of the micro space debris calibration device", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 9", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117457758", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-28", "title": "TECHNICAL ANALYSIS: TESLA SPACE STATION - 10-STARSHIP MODULAR ORBITAL CONCEPT", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 11", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117472405", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-28", "title": "TECHNICAL-STRATEGIC REPORT: INTEGRATED SPACE DEBRIS REMEDIATION SYSTEM USING STARLINK INFRASTRUCTURE", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 12", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117472975", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-28", "title": "TECHNICAL ANALYSIS: TESLA SPACE STATION - 10-STARSHIP MODULAR ORBITAL CONCEPT", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 13", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117490209", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-28", "title": "TECHNICAL-STRATEGIC REPORT: INTEGRATED SPACE DEBRIS REMEDIATION SYSTEM USING STARLINK INFRASTRUCTURE", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 14", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117518523", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-27", "title": "ILLUMINATION OF ARTIFICIAL EARTH SATELLITES IN CIRCULAR ORBITS", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 16", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117578202", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-30", "title": "Graphene light propulsion: experimental investigation, modeling, and potential application for deorbiting in low earth orbit", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 8", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117645385", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Space Mining and Environmental Hazards: Assessing India\u2019s Legal and Institutional Preparedness", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 1", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117659854", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-27", "title": "Chain Reactions in Space: Analyzing the Impact of Satellite Collisions and Debris Accumulation", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 17", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117749340", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Application of neural networks for real-time erosion monitoring and adaptive attitude/morphology control in low earth orbit/very low earth orbit", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 2", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117852075", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-27", "title": "Chain Reactions in Space: Analyzing the Impact of Satellite Collisions and Debris Accumulation", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 18", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117853320", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-27", "title": "\u041e\u0421\u0412\u0406\u0422\u041b\u0415\u041d\u0406\u0421\u0422\u042c \u0428\u0422\u0423\u0427\u041d\u0418\u0425 \u0421\u0423\u041f\u0423\u0422\u041d\u0418\u041a\u0406\u0412 \u0417\u0415\u041c\u041b\u0406 \u041d\u0410 \u041a\u041e\u041b\u041e\u0412\u0418\u0425 \u041e\u0420\u0411\u0406\u0422\u0410\u0425", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 19", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117861904", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-27", "title": "\u0415\u0412\u041e\u041b\u042e\u0426\u0406\u042f \u041f\u0410\u0420\u0410\u041c\u0415\u0422\u0420\u0406\u0412 \u041e\u0411\u0415\u0420\u0422\u0410\u041d\u041d\u042f \u0412\u0415\u0420\u0425\u041d\u042c\u041e\u0413\u041e \u0421\u0422\u0423\u041f\u0415\u041d\u042f \u0420\u0410\u041a\u0415\u0422\u0418 (\u041a\u041e\u0421\u041c\u0406\u0427\u041d\u0418\u0419 \u041e\u0411\u2019\u0404\u041a\u0422 1987-074G)", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 20", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117881239", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Low Earth Orbit Debris Collection", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 3", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7117882643", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Low Earth Orbit Debris Collection", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 4", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7126009498", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-29", "title": "Taloudellinen analyysi yksityisen sektorin kannustamiseksi v\u00e4hent\u00e4m\u00e4\u00e4n avaruusromua", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 10", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7127284309", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Space Debris and Launching State Liability: Indonesia's Legal Preparedness", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 5", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7127381861", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Analysis of Limitations of the Space Liability Convention in Regulating Space Debris in Commercial Era", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 6", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W7129748528", "source": "openalex", "published": "2025-12-31", "title": "Navigating the Cosmos: The Role of ADR in Managing Cross-Border Environmental Disputes Arising from Outer Space Debris", "selected_for": [ "relevance" ], "selection": "most-recent orbital-debris work rank 7", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W759721590", "source": "openalex", "published": "2014-01-01", "title": "Modeling the Large and Small Orbital Debris Populations for Environment Remediation", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 6", "candidates": 0 }, { "doc_id": "W834694494", "source": "openalex", "published": "2012-04-15", "title": "Optical Signature Analysis of Tumbling Rocket Bodies via Laboratory Measurements", "selected_for": [ "barriers" ], "selection": "top-cited ADR 2010-2014 rank 9", "candidates": 0 } ], "barriers": { "selection_rule": "every sampled document reduced to the sentences carrying one of barrier.py's markers, with no surrounding context, because the sentence is the receipt a reader checks; Federal Register rule bodies narrowed further to the marker sentences that also carry run.require_term, and capped at the first 40 by sentence index, since one rule runs to hundreds of them; abstracts and award texts neither narrowed nor capped", "truth_method": "docs/atlas-truth-method.md: selection rules stated there; a second reader annotated all 28 candidates independently and agreed 28/28 on barrier-or-not and 7/7 on kind", "candidates": [ { "doc_id": "2128578", "index": 5, "text": "Currently, there is a lack of systematic approaches to study various tether-net configurations and compatible autonomous control paradigms.", "kept_by": [ "truth" ] }, { "doc_id": "2128578", "index": 13, "text": "To accomplish this research goal, the following key fundamental contributions are envisioned: 1) Develop physics-infused machine learning approaches to model the complex dynamics of the net and its interactions with a target object, at computing-cost/accuracy trade-offs that are desirable for controls and design explorations. 2) Construct, compare and contrast standard centralized control architectures and novel decentralized formation control techniques to regulate the net launch and closure. 3) Explore the interplay of form (net design) and behavior (net control) in affecting capture performance, by adopting a reliability-based optimization process informed by design-adaptive neuro-controllers that will alleviate the computational burden of this concurrent control/design exploration process.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "2229756", "index": 8, "text": "Computing the optimal solutions for robust model predictive guidance and control with nonlinear constraints in real time is a significant intellectual challenge.", "kept_by": [ "truth" ] }, { "doc_id": "2229756", "index": 9, "text": "Researchers will develop a rapid optimization framework to address this challenge in solving robust and predictive optimization problems.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "2233424", "index": 7, "text": "HTV is a non-rocket technology that solves performance limitations of in-space rocket thrusters.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "2233424", "index": 11, "text": "The potential outcome of HTV research is a viable and reusable technology for cost-effective orbit object disposal in high value SSO with clean Solar Electric Propulsion (SEP).", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "2335156", "index": 0, "text": "The broader impact/commercial potential of this Phase I Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) project has far-reaching impacts that benefit the global community by offering crucial solutions to uncertain challenges encountered in space, both in Earth's orbits and deep space.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "2335156", "index": 9, "text": "The GHT addresses the limitations associated with individual technologies.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "2335156", "index": 10, "text": "It overcomes the low thrust limitation of GIT and the low specific impulse of HT, as well as mitigates the inherent process instabilities like the ionization-induced instability found in HT.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "W1831468128", "index": 0, "text": "This paper proposes a solution to perform active debris removal with a cost effective microsatellite.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2012772810", "index": 1, "text": "Orbiting debris are posing an increasing threat to operational orbits and the cascading effect, known as Kessler syndrome, may result in a future where the risk of orbiting our planet at some altitudes will be unacceptable.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "W2065606305", "index": 5, "text": "An algorithm variant is also introduced aimed at further accelerating the pose acquisition time and reducing the computational cost.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2089271685", "index": 4, "text": "This paper summarizes the key issues associated with debris removal and describes the technology and engineering challenges to move forward.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "W2119010293", "index": 2, "text": "The satellite, called CleanSpace One, will demonstrate active debris removal (ADR) in space using a small cost effective system.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2513170065", "index": 0, "text": "Existing active debris removal methods that require physical contact with the target have applicability limitations depending on the maximum angular momentum that can be absorbed.", "kept_by": [ "truth" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2562805452", "index": 8, "text": "Hybrid rocket technology for de-orbiting applications is considered a valuable option due to high specific impulse, intrinsic safety, thrust throttle ability, low environmental impact and reduced operating costs.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2763294041", "index": 3, "text": "An approximate analysis, based on the use of the J2 effect to minimize propellant consumption, provides estimations of transfer times and between any object pair in order to evaluate the costs of any possible sequence.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2788921116", "index": 0, "text": "The low-cost and short-lead time of small satellites has led to their use in science-based missions, earth observation, and interplanetary missions.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W2790442549", "index": 2, "text": "However, when designing new avionics architectures, constraints relating to the use of electronics in space present great challenges, further exacerbated by the need for significantly faster processing compared to conventional space-grade central processing units.", "kept_by": [ "truth" ] }, { "doc_id": "W3028737585", "index": 2, "text": "Collision risk from this orbital congestion is costly to satellite operators.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W3028737585", "index": 4, "text": "However, none of these approaches address the underlying incentive problem: satellite operators do not account for costs they impose on each other via collision risk.", "kept_by": [ "truth", "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W3028737585", "index": 11, "text": "In other sectors, addressing the tragedy of the commons has often been a game of catch-up with substantial social costs.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W3028737585", "index": 12, "text": "The infant space industry can avert these costs before they escalate.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W4223627349", "index": 1, "text": "Among all the challenges, the lack of available space images of the inactive satellite makes the on-ground validation of current monocular camera-based navigation systems a challenging task, mostly due to the fact that standard Image Processing (IP) algorithms, which are usually tested on synthetic images, tend to fail when implemented in orbit.", "kept_by": [ "truth" ] }, { "doc_id": "W4223627349", "index": 7, "text": "Despite the feature detection challenges under extreme brightness and illumination conditions, the results on the high exposure scenario show that the proposed system is capable of bridging the domain shift from synthetic to lab-generated images, returning accurate pose estimates for more than 50% of the rendezvous trajectory images despite the large domain gaps in target textures and illumination conditions.", "kept_by": [] }, { "doc_id": "W4321614190", "index": 1, "text": "Active debris removal (ADR) missions have gained significant interest as effective means of mitigating the risk of collision between objects in space.", "kept_by": [ "baseline" ] }, { "doc_id": "W4392923947", "index": 1, "text": "Such targets can be known or unknown, cooperative or uncooperative, and pose significant challenges in modern space operations due to their inherent complexity and unpredictability.", "kept_by": [ "truth" ] }, { "doc_id": "W4409983556", "index": 8, "text": "By consolidating recent advancements and identifying key technological gaps, this review highlights future research directions aimed at improving the reliability, adaptability, and safety of robotic manipulators in addressing the challenges of OOS and space debris removal.", "kept_by": [] } ], "records": { "truth": [ { "kind": "physical", "statement": "Currently, there is a lack of systematic approaches to study various tether-net configurations and compatible autonomous control paradigms.", "source": "nsf", "doc_id": "2128578", "published": "2021-08-10", "source_sentence": "Currently, there is a lack of systematic approaches to study various tether-net configurations and compatible autonomous control paradigms." }, { "kind": "physical", "statement": "Computing the optimal solutions for robust model predictive guidance and control with nonlinear constraints in real time is a significant intellectual challenge.", "source": "nsf", "doc_id": "2229756", "published": "2022-12-15", "source_sentence": "Computing the optimal solutions for robust model predictive guidance and control with nonlinear constraints in real time is a significant intellectual challenge." }, { "kind": "physical", "statement": "Existing active debris removal methods that require physical contact with the target have applicability limitations depending on the maximum angular momentum that can be absorbed.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2513170065", "published": "2016-09-09", "source_sentence": "Existing active debris removal methods that require physical contact with the target have applicability limitations depending on the maximum angular momentum that can be absorbed." }, { "kind": "physical", "statement": "However, when designing new avionics architectures, constraints relating to the use of electronics in space present great challenges, further exacerbated by the need for significantly faster processing compared to conventional space-grade central processing units.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2790442549", "published": "2018-02-23", "source_sentence": "However, when designing new avionics architectures, constraints relating to the use of electronics in space present great challenges, further exacerbated by the need for significantly faster processing compared to conventional space-grade central processing units." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "However, none of these approaches address the underlying incentive problem: satellite operators do not account for costs they impose on each other via collision risk.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W3028737585", "published": "2020-05-26", "source_sentence": "However, none of these approaches address the underlying incentive problem: satellite operators do not account for costs they impose on each other via collision risk." }, { "kind": "physical", "statement": "Among all the challenges, the lack of available space images of the inactive satellite makes the on-ground validation of current monocular camera-based navigation systems a challenging task, mostly due to the fact that standard Image Processing (IP) algorithms, which are usually tested on synthetic images, tend to fail when implemented in orbit.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W4223627349", "published": "2022-04-09", "source_sentence": "Among all the challenges, the lack of available space images of the inactive satellite makes the on-ground validation of current monocular camera-based navigation systems a challenging task, mostly due to the fact that standard Image Processing (IP) algorithms, which are usually tested on synthetic images, tend to fail when implemented in orbit." }, { "kind": "physical", "statement": "Such targets can be known or unknown, cooperative or uncooperative, and pose significant challenges in modern space operations due to their inherent complexity and unpredictability.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W4392923947", "published": "2024-03-01", "source_sentence": "Such targets can be known or unknown, cooperative or uncooperative, and pose significant challenges in modern space operations due to their inherent complexity and unpredictability." } ], "baseline": [ { "kind": "political", "statement": "To accomplish this research goal, the following key fundamental contributions are envisioned: 1) Develop physics-infused machine learning approaches to model the complex dynamics of the net and its interactions with a target object, at computing-cost/accuracy trade-offs that are desirable for controls and design explorations. 2) Construct, compare and contrast standard centralized control architectures and novel decentralized formation control techniques to regulate the net launch and closure. 3) Explore the interplay of form (net design) and behavior (net control) in affecting capture performance, by adopting a reliability-based optimization process informed by design-adaptive neuro-controllers that will alleviate the computational burden of this concurrent control/design exploration process.", "source": "nsf", "doc_id": "2128578", "published": "2021-08-10", "source_sentence": "To accomplish this research goal, the following key fundamental contributions are envisioned: 1) Develop physics-infused machine learning approaches to model the complex dynamics of the net and its interactions with a target object, at computing-cost/accuracy trade-offs that are desirable for controls and design explorations. 2) Construct, compare and contrast standard centralized control architectures and novel decentralized formation control techniques to regulate the net launch and closure. 3) Explore the interplay of form (net design) and behavior (net control) in affecting capture performance, by adopting a reliability-based optimization process informed by design-adaptive neuro-controllers that will alleviate the computational burden of this concurrent control/design exploration process." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "The potential outcome of HTV research is a viable and reusable technology for cost-effective orbit object disposal in high value SSO with clean Solar Electric Propulsion (SEP).", "source": "nsf", "doc_id": "2233424", "published": "2023-04-03", "source_sentence": "The potential outcome of HTV research is a viable and reusable technology for cost-effective orbit object disposal in high value SSO with clean Solar Electric Propulsion (SEP)." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "The broader impact/commercial potential of this Phase I Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) project has far-reaching impacts that benefit the global community by offering crucial solutions to uncertain challenges encountered in space, both in Earth's orbits and deep space.", "source": "nsf", "doc_id": "2335156", "published": "2024-06-12", "source_sentence": "The broader impact/commercial potential of this Phase I Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) project has far-reaching impacts that benefit the global community by offering crucial solutions to uncertain challenges encountered in space, both in Earth's orbits and deep space." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "This paper proposes a solution to perform active debris removal with a cost effective microsatellite.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W1831468128", "published": "2013-01-01", "source_sentence": "This paper proposes a solution to perform active debris removal with a cost effective microsatellite." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "An algorithm variant is also introduced aimed at further accelerating the pose acquisition time and reducing the computational cost.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2065606305", "published": "2015-03-16", "source_sentence": "An algorithm variant is also introduced aimed at further accelerating the pose acquisition time and reducing the computational cost." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "The satellite, called CleanSpace One, will demonstrate active debris removal (ADR) in space using a small cost effective system.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2119010293", "published": "2014-03-08", "source_sentence": "The satellite, called CleanSpace One, will demonstrate active debris removal (ADR) in space using a small cost effective system." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "Hybrid rocket technology for de-orbiting applications is considered a valuable option due to high specific impulse, intrinsic safety, thrust throttle ability, low environmental impact and reduced operating costs.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2562805452", "published": "2012-01-01", "source_sentence": "Hybrid rocket technology for de-orbiting applications is considered a valuable option due to high specific impulse, intrinsic safety, thrust throttle ability, low environmental impact and reduced operating costs." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "An approximate analysis, based on the use of the J2 effect to minimize propellant consumption, provides estimations of transfer times and between any object pair in order to evaluate the costs of any possible sequence.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2763294041", "published": "2017-10-04", "source_sentence": "An approximate analysis, based on the use of the J2 effect to minimize propellant consumption, provides estimations of transfer times and between any object pair in order to evaluate the costs of any possible sequence." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "The low-cost and short-lead time of small satellites has led to their use in science-based missions, earth observation, and interplanetary missions.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W2788921116", "published": "2018-02-19", "source_sentence": "The low-cost and short-lead time of small satellites has led to their use in science-based missions, earth observation, and interplanetary missions." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "Collision risk from this orbital congestion is costly to satellite operators.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W3028737585", "published": "2020-05-26", "source_sentence": "Collision risk from this orbital congestion is costly to satellite operators." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "However, none of these approaches address the underlying incentive problem: satellite operators do not account for costs they impose on each other via collision risk.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W3028737585", "published": "2020-05-26", "source_sentence": "However, none of these approaches address the underlying incentive problem: satellite operators do not account for costs they impose on each other via collision risk." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "In other sectors, addressing the tragedy of the commons has often been a game of catch-up with substantial social costs.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W3028737585", "published": "2020-05-26", "source_sentence": "In other sectors, addressing the tragedy of the commons has often been a game of catch-up with substantial social costs." }, { "kind": "economic", "statement": "The infant space industry can avert these costs before they escalate.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W3028737585", "published": "2020-05-26", "source_sentence": "The infant space industry can avert these costs before they escalate." }, { "kind": "physical", "statement": "Active debris removal (ADR) missions have gained significant interest as effective means of mitigating the risk of collision between objects in space.", "source": "openalex", "doc_id": "W4321614190", "published": "2023-02-23", "source_sentence": "Active debris removal (ADR) missions have gained significant interest as effective means of mitigating the risk of collision between objects in space." } ] }, "scores": { "baseline": { "precision": 0.07142857142857142, "recall": 0.14285714285714285, "kind_accuracy": 1.0, "found": 1, "expected": 7, "spurious": 13, "negatives_clean": 21, "negatives_total": 30, "mistyped": [], "dirtied": [ "2233424", "2335156", "W1831468128", "W2065606305", "W2119010293", "W2562805452", "W2763294041", "W2788921116", "W4321614190" ] } } }, "relevance": { "capability": "orbital-debris", "note": "the sample was drawn for the root's terms, so a label says whether a document is about the root, not whether it is about any one product", "sources": { "federal_register": { "labels": [ { "doc_id": "2014-20578", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2016-14800", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2017-04768", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2020-10703", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2020-11348", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2020-12013", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2020-13185", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2020-22042", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2021-13685", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2021-20193", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2023-12803", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2023-13503", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2023-26699", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2024-03506", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2024-16638", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2024-17093", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2024-21159", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2024-28424", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2025-12579", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2025-16375", "about": false } ], "sampled": 20, "about": 4, "precision": 0.2 }, "nsf": { "labels": [ { "doc_id": "2149585", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2208458", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2227213", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2229756", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2233424", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2323566", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2327424", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2328383", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2335156", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2343844", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2404362", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "2423107", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2423467", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2423468", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2423904", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2435391", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2435409", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2435453", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2507479", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "2530577", "about": false } ], "sampled": 20, "about": 3, "precision": 0.15 }, "openalex": { "labels": [ { "doc_id": "W7117448019", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117453191", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117457758", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117472405", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117472975", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117490209", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117518523", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117578202", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117645385", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117659854", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117749340", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117852075", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117853320", "about": false }, { "doc_id": "W7117861904", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117881239", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7117882643", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7126009498", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7127284309", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7127381861", "about": true }, { "doc_id": "W7129748528", "about": true } ], "sampled": 20, "about": 13, "precision": 0.65 } } }, "controls": { "boom": { "terms": [ "large language model" ], "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 2, 0, 2, 4, 0, 0, 3, 3, 10, 5, 4, 3, 12, 3, 4, 6, 2, 7, 15, 26, 59, 204, 945, 13605, 44909, 88754 ] }, "mature": { "terms": [ "barcode scanner" ], "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 3, 1, 3, 6, 13, 14, 14, 15, 17, 22, 26, 34, 35, 29, 35, 41, 51, 54, 47, 61, 78, 63, 53, 71, 62, 70 ] }, "all_works": { "terms": [], "source": "openalex", "first_year": 2000, "last_year": 2025, "counts": [ 3795719, 3804368, 4425085, 4705260, 5112500, 5463634, 5959728, 6488494, 6981272, 7558077, 8103309, 8694417, 8972477, 9419152, 10002808, 10158353, 10551324, 10417183, 10362032, 10734866, 11417873, 10724812, 10206156, 10844511, 10796209, 14806877 ] } }, "speculation": { "measured": false, "label": "hand-written speculation; not measured, not data", "text": "Speculation, written by hand and labelled as such; nothing here is measured.\nTwo hypotheses I hold and cannot yet test. One: AI-piloted unmanned vessels,\ndrones in orbit, will surpass crewed spaceflight for the repair, removal and\nservicing work in this chain, because none of it needs a person on board.\nTwo: humanoid robots operated through VR could make the risk of a crewed\nmission unnecessary for most of what crews do today. If either becomes\nmeasurable, it moves below the line." }, "copy": { "question": "Given the accumulation of space debris, how confidently can we predict the creation, invention, and boom of certain industries, or more specifically, products?", "description": "How far debris removal, shielding, servicing and small satellites have moved from the orbital-debris problem toward products, measured from the public record alone.", "receipts": [ "A search of NSF awards for \"orbital debris\" returned a project on recycling solar panels. Separating a document about a thing from a document that says the words is judgment, at a scale nobody does by hand; every count below carries the precision of a hand-checked sample.", "The citation data behind the edges cost real money to fetch: the index meters free use by spend, and this chain needed three days of allowance." ], "limitations": [ "One annotator typed every barrier; the second reader's agreement is printed under Method in the barriers block.", "The index meters free use by spend, so the citation layer was fetched over three days and any re-run costs the same again." ], "next": [ "Run a second chain with the same machinery, unchanged, and publish whatever it shows.", "Widen the truth set toward the kinds it lacks, starting with space law for political barriers.", "Add a disposal pass as its own capability, since the regulator writes about disposal where I searched for removal." ], "method_doc": "docs/atlas-truth-method.md" }, "run": { "barrier_prompt_version": "a5ce1358ce2b", "capability": "active debris removal", "corpora": { "orbital-debris": { "fetched": 11518, "distinct": 11476, "repeated": 42, "meta_count": 11501 }, "active-debris-removal": { "fetched": 1038, "distinct": 1037, "repeated": 1, "meta_count": 1038 }, "debris-shielding": { "fetched": 1489, "distinct": 1487, "repeated": 2, "meta_count": 1487 }, "on-orbit-servicing": { "fetched": 2274, "distinct": 2272, "repeated": 2, "meta_count": 2273 }, "small-satellites": { "fetched": 25078, "distinct": 25009, "repeated": 69, "meta_count": 25055 }, "barcode-scanner": { "fetched": 923, "distinct": 920, "repeated": 3, "meta_count": 920 } }, "cutoff": "2025-12-31", "dropped": [], "max_tokens": 4096, "model": null, "no_model": true, "prompt_version": "59b43399197f", "require_term": null, "require_term_note": "no term was required at run time; 'removal' was applied to Federal Register rule bodies when the sample was built, so those three bodies arrive already narrowed to marker sentences carrying it, while abstracts and award texts were never narrowed", "selection_rules": { "barriers_openalex": "the 10 most-cited works naming the ADR research terms in each of 2010-2014, 2015-2019 and 2020-2025, restricted to works carrying an abstract; text is the inverted index put back into reading order", "barriers_nsf": "every award for the ADR funding terms over 2000-2025; text is the award's abstract", "barriers_federal_register": "the 3 most recent final rules whose title carries 'orbital debris', each body reduced with barrier_passages(body, require_term='removal') and capped at the first 40 candidates by sentence index; text is that reduction, which is empty for all three", "relevance": "the 20 most recent keyword matches per source for the root's terms, labelled about or not about from the document's title and text", "gate": "Corpus.as_of(2025-12-31), applied twice. At sample-build time it excluded Federal Register rule 2026-14673, published 2026-07-21, which is why the sample holds 91 documents and not 92. This run re-gates all 91 through the same cutoff and excludes none of them, since the sample it reads was already gated; the second pass is what makes the first one checkable rather than asserted" }, "temperature": null, "user_agent": "raven-research/0.1 (mailto:caelan.gander@gmail.com)" } }